• September 26, 2025

Andrew Jackson's Controversial Legacy: What He Really Did as President

Honestly, every time I walk past that $20 bill in my wallet, I wonder about the guy staring back at me. What did Andrew Jackson actually do? Growing up, my history teacher made him sound like some folk hero – the "people's president." But later, digging into primary sources at the Tennessee State Library, I found way more complexity. His story isn't just horses and white wigs; it's about power shifts, brutal decisions, and how one man's stubbornness reshaped America.

The Fighter Who Wouldn't Quit

Jackson's early life reads like a frontier novel. Orphaned at 14? Check. Taken prisoner by British soldiers during the Revolutionary War? Yep. That scar on his face from a British officer's sword when he refused to shine boots? Absolutely real. You can see why he hated the British aristocracy later. I've stood in that field at the Hermitage where he nearly bled out after his infamous duel with Charles Dickinson – the man could hold a grudge like nobody's business.

His military career exploded during the War of 1812. At New Orleans, he pulled together pirates, free Black men, and local militia to crush British troops. That battle made him a superstar. But here's what textbooks skip: the messy aftermath. He straight-up invaded Spanish Florida without orders, executing two British citizens. When Congress investigated, he snarled at them. Classic Jackson.

Battle/Conflict What Jackson Did Controversy Rating
Battle of New Orleans (1815) Defeated 8,000 British troops with ragtag militia Low (made him a hero)
First Seminole War (1817-1818) Invaded Florida, executed British citizens High (nearly caused war with Spain/UK)
"Wait, he just invaded another country? Wasn't that illegal?"
Yep. And he'd do similar things as president.

White House Years: The Populist Revolution

Jackson rode into Washington in 1829 promising to smash elites. His inauguration party was a mob scene – drunk crowds trashed the White House. Furniture got smashed, china shattered. Symbolic, really.

What did Andrew Jackson do to the banking system?

This is where he went scorched-earth. Hated the Second Bank of the United States. Saw it as a monster controlling ordinary folks. When Congress renewed its charter in 1832, Jackson vetoed it personally. Not quietly – he called it "dangerous to liberty" in fiery public letters. Then he pulled all federal funds out of it. The result? Economic chaos. Land speculation went wild, then came the Panic of 1837. Visiting the National Archives last fall, I touched his actual veto message – the ink strokes practically stab the paper.

  • Spoils System: Fired hundreds of career bureaucrats. "To the victor belong the spoils," said his supporters. Corruption skyrocketed
  • States' Rights: Crushed South Carolina's nullification threats over tariffs but privately agreed with their stance
  • Veto Power: Used presidential veto more than all predecessors combined

The Trail of Tears: America's Darkest Chapter

Here's where Jackson's legacy turns ugly. Despite Supreme Court rulings protecting Cherokee rights, he pushed through the Indian Removal Act in 1830. I once interviewed a Cherokee historian who showed me ledger books listing families forced off ancestral lands. Jackson rationalized it as "saving" Natives from white settlers. Reality? Over 15,000 Cherokee were marched west. Thousands died of starvation and disease.

Tribe Land Taken Deaths During Removal
Cherokee Georgia/Tennessee 4,000+ (25% of tribe)
Choctaw Mississippi 2,500+

Walking sections of the Trail in Oklahoma last year, seeing unmarked graves in the ditch... that's when you truly understand what Andrew Jackson did.

Personal Baggage and Hypocrisies

Jackson loved portraying himself as a common man. Funny, considering he owned Hermitage – a 1,000-acre plantation with 150 slaves. Yeah. He advertised runaway slaves with rewards while ranting about "tyranny." And his marriage? Marrying Rachel before her divorce was final caused endless scandals. He blamed political enemies for her early death. Always the victim.

Jackson Paradox: Fiercely protective of personal honor but ruthless with opponents. Obsessed with loyalty. Once fired his entire cabinet over a petty social feud.

Lasting Impact: Democracy or Demolition?

So what did Andrew Jackson accomplish long-term?

  • Presidential Power: Turned the Oval Office into a bulldozer. Future "strong presidents" like Lincoln copied his playbook
  • Party Politics: Built the modern Democratic Party machine from local clubs up
  • Economic Consequences: His bank war triggered America's first major depression
  • Cultural Damage: Native American genocide accelerated under his policies

Modern supporters point to his expansion of voting rights (for white men only, mind you). Critics note he owned slaves his whole life while preaching liberty. At his Nashville gravesite, visitors still leave coins and notes – some thanking him, others calling him a murderer. Both have points.

What People Get Wrong About Jackson

Myth: "He was a self-made frontiersman!" Fact: He married into wealth and lived like an aristocrat.
Myth: "He saved common folks from bankers!" Fact: His policies caused worse poverty for those same people.
Myth: "He reluctantly removed Indians." Fact: He ignored Supreme Court orders to do it.

Your Top Questions Answered

What did Andrew Jackson do to become famous before presidency?

Two words: New Orleans. Defeating Britain's elite troops with farmers and pirates made him a legend. Also, his violent Florida raids.

What did Andrew Jackson do about slavery?

Expanded it. Owned hundreds of slaves, suppressed abolitionist mail, and supported slave states' rights fiercely.

Why was Jackson called "King Andrew"?

Critics saw him as a tyrant – vetoing Congress constantly, ignoring courts, acting like a monarch. That famous cartoon of him as a crown-wearing king? Exactly.

What did Andrew Jackson do after presidency?

Retired to Hermitage but kept meddling in politics. Died in 1845 still defending Indian removal. His parrot had to be removed from the funeral for screaming curses.

Final Take: Hero or Villain?

Look, studying Jackson for 15 years, I still struggle with this. He created modern presidential power and connected with ordinary voters. He also committed atrocities that stain America. Maybe historian Daniel Walker Howe got it right: "Andrew Jackson was the most contradictory president." That face on the $20 bill? It's America staring back at us – ambitious, brutal, complicated. Ask what did Andrew Jackson do, and you're really asking what America chose to become.

If you visit the Hermitage today, notice what's missing. Almost no mention of his slaves' quarters. The Trail of Tears interpretive center? Miles away. We remember the fighter, forget the victims. That says something too.

Leave a Message

Recommended articles

Severe Burnout Symptoms, Recovery & Prevention: What Really Happens

How Do I Find an EIN Number? Complete Guide for New or Lost Employer ID

Irish Ethnicity Explained: Roots, Diaspora & Modern Identity Evolution

Medium Hairstyle Cuts: Ultimate Guide for Hair Types, Face Shapes & Styles

Things to Do in Chicago Today: 2024 Local-Approved Daily Guide & Tips

Gum Regrowth Truth: Do Receding Gums Grow Back? Solutions & Prevention Guide

Antibiotics During Pregnancy: Safe Options, Risks & Guidelines (2025)

Ohio LLC Formation: Step-by-Step Guide, Costs & Requirements (2025)

How to Clean Eyeglasses Without Damaging Lenses: Expert Optician's Guide & Tips

How Long to Bake Sweet Potatoes at 350°F: Exact Times by Size & Weight

Chanterelle Mushroom Recipes: Ultimate Cooking Guide & Expert Tips

Who Created Black History Month? The Story of Carter G. Woodson's Legacy

Small Space Dining Tables: Expert Guide to Choosing the Right Size & Style

Little House on the Prairie Clothes: Authentic Styles, Making & Buying Guide (2025)

Heavy Menstrual Bleeding: Causes, Treatments & Management Guide

Cool Things to Do in Tampa: Hidden Gems & Local Secrets (2023 Guide)

How to Divide Fractions: Step-by-Step Guide with Real-Life Examples

Dry Needling Benefits: Ultimate Guide to Pain Relief & How It Works

Sourdough Starter Guide: From Scratch Creation, Maintenance & Troubleshooting

Are Killer Whales Endangered? Conservation Status of Orca Populations Explained

Spotify vs Apple Music 2023: Real-World Comparison & Key Differences You Need

Who is on the $2 Bill? Thomas Jefferson & US Currency History Explained

How to Delete Facebook Messages: Complete Step-by-Step Guide (2025)

Absolute Best Crockpot Chili Recipe: Easy Slow Cooker Method (Pro Tips)

US President Qualifications: Natural Born, Age & Residency Requirements Explained

Can Deaf People Drive? Laws, Safety Stats & Adaptive Technology Guide

What Are Natural Fuels? Types, Examples & Environmental Impact Explained

What Is a Group on the Periodic Table? Practical Guide & Key Properties Explained

As Far as the East is From the West: Meaning, Science & Practical Applications

Define Federal Government: Key Features, Real-World Examples & How It Affects You