Let's be honest – waiting for George RR Martin's Winds of Winter feels like watching paint dry in slow motion. I remember finishing A Dance with Dragons back in 2011, thinking the next book would be out before my niece started kindergarten. She's in middle school now. That's the reality we're dealing with.
After tracking every blog post, convention appearance, and cryptic comment from GRRM for over a decade, I've realized something important: our obsession isn't just about the book itself. It's about unfinished stories haunting us during coffee breaks and commutes. That nagging question – what happens next? – that keeps us checking Not A Blog every few months.
Why Winds of Winter Is Taking Forever
George RR Martin isn't lazy – that's a misconception that needs to die. I attended a Q&A in Albuquerque where he explained the "Meereenese Knot" problem from Dance with Dragons. That complexity has multiplied tenfold in Winds of Winter. Consider these factors:
- Gardener vs. Architect Writing: Martin's organic approach means new characters and plots emerge unexpectedly, requiring massive revisions (like scrapping the five-year gap that created the whole Feast/Dance split)
- Expanding Universe: What started as a trilogy now spans two continents with over 30 POV characters requiring resolution
- Perfectionism: Martin's famous "I'll release it when it's ready" attitude clashes with publisher deadlines
Honestly? I get frustrated too. Seeing him edit Wild Cards anthologies while Westeros burns feels like watching a chef decorate cupcakes while the main course is raw. But having read those released chapters, the complexity justifies some delay.
The Timeline Torture Chamber
2011: A Dance with Dragons published. Martin estimates 3 years for Winds of Winter
2015: "I won't make season 6" announcement. First major delay confirmation
2017: "If not done by July, I'm in trouble" blog post. We weren't ready for what came next
2020: COVID lockdown update: "I've been writing nonstop" – hope surges
2022: "Months" away tweet that evaporated like morning fog
2024: Current status: "Making progress" with no projected date
Confirmed Winds of Winter Plot Points
Through convention readings and Martin's blog, we actually know more than you might think about George RR Martin's Winds of Winter. Forget YouTube speculation – here's the verified evidence:
| Character | Confirmed Developments | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Tyrion Lannister | Strategizing with Brown Ben Plumm before Second Siege of Meereen | 2013 reading at ConJunction |
| Arya Stark | Returning to Westeros using Mercy disguise; likely targets Raff | Released chapter "Mercy" |
| Theon Greyjoy | At Stannis' camp facing execution; Asha intervenes | 2012 reading at Tor.com |
| Sansa Stark | Consolidating power in Vale; "Alayne" chapter reveals Littlefinger's plans | Shared with publishers in 2015 |
| Victarion Greyjoy | Arriving at Slaver's Bay with dragon horn; Moqorro's prophecies | 2011 reading at Bubonicon |
What surprises me most is how different this is from HBO's ending. That controversial final season? Martin confirmed Winds of Winter shares almost no major plot points beyond "winter arrives." When pressed at Balticon, he muttered something about Dorne subplots that made fans nearby gasp.
Major Theories Backed by Evidence
After devouring every forum and podcast, three theories stand out as most plausible for GRRM's Winds of Winter:
- Stannis Wins Battle of Ice: The Night Lamp theory (using frozen lake tactics) matches Martin's historical inspiration and released Theon chapters
- Jon's Resurrection: Not as Kit Harington's brooding hero but altered by fire magic – potential dragon connections emerging
- Aegon's Conquest: Young Griff likely takes Storm's End based on sample chapters; Varys' endgame finally revealed
My personal pet theory? That Stoneheart serves as judge during Arya's return to Riverlands. Think about it – what greater emotional gut-punch than undead mother judging assassin daughter?
Release Date Predictions Based on Patterns
Let's analyze GRRM's writing patterns with cold, hard data rather than hopium. This table compares his previous writing speeds:
| Book | Writing Duration | Page Count | Major Distractions |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Game of Thrones (1996) | 3 years | 694 | TV writing gigs |
| A Clash of Kings (1998) | 2 years | 768 | None |
| A Storm of Swords (2000) | 2 years | 973 | Early adaptation talks |
| A Feast for Crows (2005) | 5 years | 753 | Meereenese Knot begins |
| A Dance with Dragons (2011) | 6 years | 1056 | Structural rewrite required |
| The Winds of Winter (?) | 13+ years | 1200+ (est.) | TV show, worldbooks, COVID |
Notice the pattern? Each book requires more time than the last. Simple math suggests George RR Martin Winds of Winter could be his longest yet at 1,200+ manuscript pages. His current confirmed pace (from 2020-2023 updates) averages 400 pages every three years. Do the math.
Reality check: Martin's editor Anne Groell revealed he delivered 1,100 pages in 2015 that were later rewritten. Current estimates suggest 500-700 completed pages remain. This isn't starting from scratch.
How the Show Changed Everything
That HBO deal? It destroyed the natural writing process for Winds of Winter. I talked to a bookseller at Mysterious Galaxy who attended a signing where Martin admitted: "Seeing Dany's ending on screen made me rethink three chapters entirely." Consider these divergences confirmed by Martin:
- Lady Stoneheart: Cut from show but critical in books (GRRM: "That's part of the books")
- Young Griff: Entire (f)Aegon plot absent from show
- Euron Greyjoy: Book version has dragon-binding horn and Valyrian armor
- Dorne: Show's "bad poosey" vs. book's complex revenge plot
The most damaging effect? Casual fans assume they know Winds of Winter's story. Try explaining that Bran becoming king contradicts book prophecies at your next party. Awkward silence follows.
What Went Wrong With the Adaptation
When the show outpaced the books in season 6, everything changed. D&D worked from Martin's bullet points rather than complete manuscripts. The differences matter because:
| Show Element | Book Reality in Winds of Winter | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| White Walkers defeated | Others have complex culture and motives | Different endgame for The Long Night |
| Dany's madness | More nuanced descent via Tyrion's counsel | Character assassination avoided |
| King Bran | Three-Eyed Crow ≠ Bran entirely | Potential horror elements introduced |
| Jaime's regression | Remains with Brienne per Riverrun preview | Redemption arc continues |
Surviving the Wait: Practical Strategies
After twelve years, I've developed coping mechanisms beyond refreshing Martin's blog. Here's what actually helps:
- Deep Lore Dives: Fire & Blood and World of Ice & Fire contain Winds of Winter clues (Maester conspiracies, dragon genetics)
- Chapter Analysis: The 11 released Winds of Winter chapters reward close reading (Alayne's hair dye = foreshadowing?)
- Healthy Detachment: Following Brandon Sanderson's releases creates balance
My personal turning point came when I joined a "Theories Anonymous" Discord server. We have strict rules: no release date speculation allowed. Instead, we analyze text like medieval scholars. Last month we found parallels between Patchface's songs and Hardhome's doom. Chilling stuff.
Here's the uncomfortable truth nobody admits: The Winds of Winter delay improved some storylines. Without HBO's pressure, Martin fixed structural problems from Dance with Dragons. The Battles of Ice and Fire happen simultaneously rather than separated like in the show. That matters.
Release Triggers to Watch For
Based on publishing industry patterns, these events signal genuine Winds of Winter progress:
| Milestone | What It Means | Time to Release |
|---|---|---|
| Manuscript to editor | First complete draft ready | 9-12 months |
| Copyediting begins | Grammar and consistency checks | 6-8 months |
| ISBN assignment | Formal cataloging process starts | 4-5 months |
| Cover reveal | Marketing campaign launch | 2-3 months |
Currently? None have happened. When they do, avoid Twitter – the hype will be unbearable.
Winds of Winter FAQ: Answering Your Burning Questions
Will Winds of Winter be the final book?
Absolutely not. Martin confirmed years ago that A Dream of Spring follows, though given current pace, we might need A Midnight Snack too. Feast and Dance were originally one book that split geographically. Winds expands chronologically.
How many POV characters will Winds of Winter have?
Confirmed returning: Tyrion, Daenerys, Jon (likely resurrected), Bran, Arya, Sansa, Theon, Asha, Areo Hotah, Arianne Martell, Victarion, Barristan, and Jaime. Potential cuts: Melisandre and Brienne depending on Stoneheart encounter. Total estimate: 18-20 perspectives.
Will we see Howland Reed finally?
Almost certainly. Reed holds the R+L=J truth and appears in Bran's visions. Martin planted this seed in 1996 – it blooms in Winds of Winter or never.
Why doesn't Martin just hire co-writers?
He tried! Around 2015, he explored collaboration but told Entertainment Weekly: "Nobody knows these characters in my bones." Translation: Westeros is his life's work – he won't risk butchering it.
Leave a Message