You know how it goes. You're arguing with buddies at the rink or scrolling through hockey forums late at night, and the same question pops up: who truly belongs among the top hockey players of all time? Problem is, most lists feel like they were copied from some dusty encyclopedia. Let's fix that.
I've spent way too many hours watching grainy footage of 1950s games and comparing stats that shouldn't even exist in the same conversation. My basement's full of VHS tapes my wife wants me to throw out. Why? Because comparing eras is messy, but someone's gotta do it right.
The Greatness Formula (It's Not Just Points)
Forget those lazy rankings based solely on career points. We weighed five key factors:
1. Peak Dominance - How terrifying were they at their absolute best?
2. Trophy Case - Hardware matters (Hart, Norris, Vezina, Cups)
3. Longevity - Sustained excellence > short bursts
4. Era Impact - Did they change how the game was played?
5. "Clutch Gene" - Big goals when seasons were on the line
The Undisputed Mount Rushmore
These four names appear on virtually every legitimate list of the greatest hockey players ever. Disagree? Fight me.
Wayne Gretzky
Center 1961-1999Why he's here: Owns or shares 61 NHL records. His 2,857 career points? Next closest is Jaromir Jagr at 1,921. That's like outscoring Michael Jordan by 10,000 points. Won 9 MVP awards. Made hockey mainstream in California. Honestly? He broke the sport.
Flaw to note: Defense wasn't his priority. Minus-21 in 1993 playoffs.
Bobby Orr
Defenseman 1948-1979Why he's here: Revolutionized defense. Only blueliner to win the Art Ross (scoring title). Still holds single-season plus/minus record at +124. Won 8 straight Norris Trophies. Played through destroyed knees that would bench anyone today.
Painful truth: Career ended at 30. Makes you wonder what could've been.
Gordie Howe
Right Wing 1928-2016Why he's here: The original iron man. Played pro hockey across FIVE decades. "Gordie Howe Hat Trick" (goal, assist, fight) entered lexicon for a reason. Top-5 in scoring for 20 straight seasons. Terrifying combination of skill and menace.
Controversial take: Never had Gretzky's peak scoring dominance.
Maurice "Rocket" Richard
Right Wing 1921-2000Why he's here: First to score 50 goals in 50 games (1945). His intensity sparked the 1955 Richard Riot in Montreal. Won 8 Cups with the Habs. More than stats, he was hockey's fiery soul for French Canada.
Reality check: Career points (966) look modest today. Different era.
The Elite Tier: Arguments Start Here
Splitting hairs between these legends hurts my brain. But since you asked...
| Player | Position | Career Span | Signature Achievement | Underrated Fact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mario Lemieux | Center | 1984-2006 | Overcame cancer to win scoring title | 2.01 PPG - highest ever |
| Dominik Hasek | Goalie | 1990-2011 | Only goalie with 2 MVP awards | .922 career save % (best pre-2000s) |
| Jean Beliveau | Center | 1950-1971 | 17 Stanley Cups (player + exec) | Never took a penalty in 13 playoff runs |
| Doug Harvey | Defenseman | 1947-1969 | 7 Norris Trophies | Modernized puck-moving defense |
| Bobby Hull | Left Wing | 1957-1980 | First to score >50 goals | Slapshot clocked at 118 mph (1960s!) |
Watching Hasek flop around like a trout in 1998 Olympics changed how I saw goaltending forever. Looked ridiculous. Worked like witchcraft.
Goalies: The Impossible Evaluation
Comparing goalies across generations feels unfair. Equipment changed. Shooters got deadlier. Rules shifted. But ignoring these wall-builders would be criminal when debating the top hockey players ever.
Goalie Greatness Grid
| Name | Era | Save % | Vezinas | Signature Move | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patrick Roy | 1985-2003 | .910 | 3 | Butterfly stance | Rebound control |
| Martin Brodeur | 1991-2015 | .912 | 4 | Puck handling | Weak glove side |
| Terry Sawchuk | 1949-1970 | N/A* | 4 | Angled positioning | Struggled with high shots |
| Ken Dryden | 1970-1979 | .922 | 5 | Stand-up style | Short career |
*Save % not tracked until 1982
Sawchuk played without a mask half his career. Let that sink in. Pucks to the face were Tuesday.
Modern Masters Changing the Conversation
Sidney Crosby and Alex Ovechkin force their way into the top hockey players of all time debate. Here's how their resumes stack against legends:
| Metric | Crosby | Ovechkin | Gretzky | Lemieux |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Points/Game | 1.28 | 1.12 | 1.92 | 2.01 |
| Hart Trophies | 2 | 3 | 9 | 3 |
| Cups Won | 3 | 1 | 4 | 2 |
| Clutch Points** | 1.28 | 0.91 | 1.97 | 1.93 |
**Points per game in playoffs
Ovi's chasing Gretzky's goal record (894 vs 801 as of 2023). But Sid's two-way play? Reminds me of Steve Yzerman's transformation into a complete beast.
Connor McDavid's coming. But he needs Cups to crash this party.
The Heartbreakers: Careers That Left Us Wanting
Some players crack top hockey players of all time debates purely on unrealized potential:
- Pavel Bure - Knees betrayed the "Russian Rocket". Scored 59 goals twice before injuries hit.
- Eric Lindros - MVP at 21. Concussions derailed a HOF trajectory.
- Mike Bossy - 573 goals in 752 games. Retired at 30 with chronic back issues.
Bossy haunts me. Dude averaged 57 goals per 82 games. Imagine 5 more healthy seasons.
Your Burning Questions Answered
Is Wayne Gretzky overrated because he played in a high-scoring era?
Not even slightly. Adjusted for era, his 1986 season (215 points) translates to 167 points in 2023 - still 40+ more than McDavid's best season. He outscored contemporaries by wider margins than anyone.
Why is Bobby Orr ranked above modern defensemen like Nicklas Lidstrom?
Orr changed the position permanently. Pre-Orr, defensemen rarely crossed center ice. His offensive output (+139 one year!) remains insane. Lidstrom was perfection for longer, but Orr's peak was cosmic.
How important are Stanley Cups in judging individuals?
Less than fans think. Marcel Dionne (731 goals) never won one. Dave Andreychuk won his only Cup at 40. Team accomplishment ≠ individual greatness. But sustained playoff excellence? That matters.
Who'd be higher if international play counted more?
Vladislav Tretiak skyrockets. The Soviet wall dominated best-on-best tournaments before NHL participation. Beat Team Canada in 1972 Summit Series with a .940 save percentage. Unreal.
The Final Whistle
Arguing about the absolute top hockey players of all time is half the fun. I've changed my own rankings twice while writing this. Stats help, but hockey greatness lives in those moments that freeze arenas: Orr flying through the air, Ovi's one-timer from his office, Hasek's desperation paddle save.
Crosby might crack the top-five when he hangs them up. McDavid's speed could rewrite record books. But Gretzky's vision? Orr's revolutionary grace? Howe's terrifying longevity? That's Mount Olympus stuff.
What surprises me most? How many franchise-altering greats never won individual awards. Steve Yzerman sacrificed scoring titles for Cups. Ray Bourque waited 23 years for his ring. That grit matters too when we talk about the greatest ever.
Now grab your stick and argue with your friends. Just don't throw gloves like it's 1975.
Leave a Message