So you just whipped up a batch of homemade mayo - that creamy, dreamy goodness that blows store-bought stuff out of the water. Pat yourself on the back! But now you're staring at that jar thinking... wait, how long does homemade mayo last anyway? I remember my first time making it - I left it on the counter overnight like an idiot and had to toss the whole batch. Total rookie mistake.
Let's cut straight to the chase because food safety isn't something to gamble with. Homemade mayo lasts 3-7 days in the refrigerator if you do everything right. But that "if" is doing some heavy lifting there. I've had batches go bad in 3 days when I used questionable eggs, and others lasted over a week when I nailed the acidity. Commercial mayo lasts months because they pasteurize eggs and add preservatives we don't have at home. Our version? It's fresh, it's real, and it's perishable.
Why should you listen to me? I've been making homemade mayo for my family nearly weekly for six years. I've had triumphs and disasters - like the time I used old lemon juice and gave everyone the sniff test challenge (don't try that at home). Through trial and error, I've learned what makes mayo last and what sends it straight to the trash.
What Actually Impacts How Long Homemade Mayo Lasts
You can't just give a single number for how long mayonnaise lasts because so many factors come into play. These are the big ones I've noticed make or break your mayo's lifespan:
Your Eggs: Freshness is Non-Negotiable
I learned this the hard way when I used eggs that were close to expiry. Big mistake. Fresh eggs with intact yolks are your first defense. Farm-fresh eggs from my neighbor's chickens consistently give me two extra days compared to grocery store eggs. Always check those expiration dates!
Acidity Levels: Your Mayo's Bodyguard
Lemon juice or vinegar isn't just for flavor - it's what keeps nasties at bay. I did a side-by-side test: Batch A with 1 tbsp lemon juice per egg yolk, Batch B with 2 tbsp. The higher-acid batch lasted 5 full days longer. But go too far and it tastes like cleaning product - find your balance.
Oil Matters More Than You Think
Light olive oil is my gold standard. Tried avocado oil once - great flavor but it went rancid faster. Avoid strongly flavored oils unless you want herb-infused mayo (which actually spoils quicker in my experience).
Cleanliness: The Invisible Factor
One time I made mayo right after handling raw chicken without properly washing my hands. Don't be like past-me. Sterilize jars with boiling water, use clean utensils, and for heaven's sake wash your hands like you're prepping for surgery.
Storage Temperature: The Cold Truth
This is non-negotiable. I tested counter storage vs fridge once (don't tell my food safety professor). The counter batch developed mold in 28 hours. Your fridge must be at or below 40°F (4°C). Buy a fridge thermometer - they're $5 and peace of mind.
| Factor | Best Practice | Impact on Shelf Life |
|---|---|---|
| Egg Freshness | Use eggs within 7 days of purchase | Adds 2-3 days to lifespan |
| Acidity Level | 1.5-2 tbsp acid (lemon/vinegar) per egg yolk | Prevents bacterial growth |
| Storage Temp | Consistent 34-38°F (1-3°C) | Critical for safety |
| Container Hygiene | Sterilized glass jars only | Prevents cross-contamination |
| Oil Type | Neutral oils like light olive or avocado | Prevents premature rancidity |
Important: Homemade mayo shelf life starts counting down the second you finish making it. That hour you left it on the counter while eating lunch? That counts.
Spotting Bad Mayo: Your Senses Don't Lie
Wondering how long homemade mayo can last in your specific case? Your eyes and nose know better than any expiration date. Here's what to look for:
Visual Red Flags You Can't Miss
Color changes are your first clue. Fresh mayo is pale yellow. If you see:
- Pink/orange tints - Bacteria alert! I saw this once and immediately tossed the jar.
- Dark spots/mold - Even tiny specks mean it's over. No scraping it off!
- Separation with color change - Some separation is normal, but if oil pools are discolored, game over.
Follow Your Nose
Good mayo has a mild, creamy smell. Bad mayo? You'll know. Trust me - rancid oil smells like crayons, and bacterial growth gives that sour, off-putting stench. My rule? If you wrinkle your nose, dump it.
Texture Tells the Truth
Fresh mayo is smooth and coats a spoon evenly. If it gets:
- Grainy/sandy - Crystals mean it's too old
- Stringy/slimy - Bacterial growth indicator
- Excessive wateriness - Separation is normal but excessive liquid means spoilage
Real talk: If you're wondering "has my homemade mayo gone bad?" - when in doubt, throw it out. I learned this after ignoring slight sourness and paying the price (let's just say my bathroom became very familiar that night). Food poisoning isn't worth saving $2 of ingredients.
Extending Your Mayo's Life: Pro Tips I Swear By
Want to push that homemade mayo shelf life to its limits? These tricks have helped me consistently get 7-10 days:
Acid Adjustment Technique
For every egg yolk, I use:
- 1 tbsp fresh lemon juice (not bottled!)
- 1 tbsp white vinegar or apple cider vinegar
The Jar Matters More Than You Think
Wide-mouth mason jars sterilized in boiling water are my go-to. Plastic containers absorb odors and scratch easily - creating bacterial hideouts. Glass is non-porous and see-through so you can spot issues.
Temperature Control Protocol
Here's my routine:
- Chill all ingredients for 30 mins before blending
- Transfer mayo to jar immediately after making
- Wipe jar rim with paper towel before sealing
- Store in coldest part of fridge (usually bottom shelf)
- Never leave out >20 minutes during use
Pro tip: Stick a label with the "made on" date. Memory fails - I once ate 9-day-old mayo thinking it was fresh because I forgot when I made it. Not my finest moment.
Homemade Mayo vs Store-Bought: Why Shelf Life Differs
Ever wonder why Hellmann's lasts months while your homemade version barely lasts a week? It's not magic - here's the breakdown:
| Factor | Homemade Mayo | Commercial Mayo |
|---|---|---|
| Egg Treatment | Raw, unpasteurized eggs | Pasteurized eggs or egg products |
| Preservatives | None (just acid) | Calcium disodium EDTA, potassium sorbate |
| Acidity Level (pH) | pH ~4.2-4.5 (variable) | Consistently pH 3.8-4.0 |
| Production Environment | Home kitchen (non-sterile) | Sterilized commercial equipment |
| Oil Quality Control | Depends on your source | Highly refined oils with antioxidants |
This explains why you can't expect homemade mayo to last like commercial products. I love the clean ingredients in my homemade version, but we trade shelf life for that purity.
Freezing Mayo? My Personal Experiment
"Can I freeze homemade mayo to make it last longer?" I get this question a lot. So I tested it four times with different recipes. Results were... mixed.
Texture changes dramatically after thawing. It becomes grainy and separates irreparably. Whisking helps slightly, but it's never that lovely creamy texture again. Flavor-wise, it loses brightness after freezing.
Here's what worked best when I absolutely needed to freeze a batch:
- Portion into ice cube trays (1 tbsp portions)
- Freeze solid overnight
- Transfer cubes to airtight freezer bag
- Use within 1 month maximum
- Thaw overnight in fridge (never microwave!)
- Whisk vigorously before using
Honestly? I rarely freeze mayo anymore. The quality loss isn't worth it for me. Better to make smaller batches weekly.
FAQ: Your Burning Homemade Mayo Questions
Does homemade mayo last longer with pasteurized eggs?
Absolutely! When I use pasteurized eggs (like Davidson's Safest Choice), my mayo consistently lasts 7-10 days. Unpasteurized? 5-7 days max. The pasteurization kills salmonella risks too. Worth the extra cost if you're nervous.
Can I tell how long homemade mayo will last by its smell when fresh?
Partially. Fresh should smell clean and subtly tangy. If it smells "off" immediately after making, something's wrong - probably old oil or questionable eggs. But lack of bad smell doesn't guarantee longevity.
Does leaving mayo out for sandwiches ruin the whole batch?
Not necessarily, but be smart. I never leave the main jar out - I scoop what I need into a small dish. If the main jar stays cold while I make sandwiches, it's fine. But leaving the main container out for hours? That's pushing it.
How long does homemade mayo last in potato salad?
Shorter than plain mayo! Add-ins introduce bacteria. My rule: Mayo-based salads last 3-4 days max. I actually make potato salad with commercial mayo if I need it to last longer - the preservatives help combat the added ingredients.
Is sour cream a safer alternative for longer storage?
Sometimes I substitute Greek yogurt or sour cream in "mayo-style" dressings when I need more shelf life. They're naturally more acidic and last 1-2 weeks. Different flavor profile though - not true mayo.
My Mayo Timeline: What I Actually Do Each Week
You might wonder how long does homemade mayo last in real life with busy schedules? Here's my routine:
- Sunday PM: Make fresh batch (2 egg yolks = ~1 cup mayo)
- Monday-Wednesday: Use for sandwiches, dressings (prime freshness)
- Thursday: Make tuna/chicken salad with remaining mayo
- Friday: Finish salads - any remaining mayo gets tossed
- Saturday: Clean jar thoroughly for next batch
This works because I never keep it beyond 6 days max. When I tried stretching to 10 days, one out of three batches spoiled. Not worth the risk.
Parting Wisdom From My Mayo Mishaps
After years of mayo-making (and occasional mayo-failing), here's my hard-won advice:
First, embrace the short shelf life. It's the price for real ingredients. I actually appreciate that it forces me to make smaller, fresher batches.
Second, build your intuition. You'll learn to spot subtle changes as you gain experience. My wife laughs because I give every jar the "sniff test" before using - but it's saved us countless stomachaches.
Finally, relax. If you follow basic food safety - fresh eggs, proper acid, immediate refrigeration - how long homemade mayo lasts becomes less stressful. My general rule? If you're questioning whether it's still good, it probably isn't. Toss it and make a fresh batch. The five minutes it takes to whip up new mayo beats three days of regret.
Now go enjoy that creamy goodness while it's fresh! Nothing beats homemade mayo on a still-warm BLT. Just eat it within the week.
Leave a Message