Okay, let's be real. Getting laid off stinks. Been there myself twice in my career. First time was at 29 when the startup I worked for tanked. They offered three months' pay, and I thought "great, breathing room!" Then I saw my first severance check. Nearly choked on my coffee. Taxes had taken nearly 40% of it. That's when I realized what nobody tells you: how severance pay is taxed changes everything.
Severance pay isn't bonus money. It's taxed differently than your regular paycheck, and if you don't plan for it, you could end up with way less than expected. Honestly, I wish someone had explained this stuff before I got that first surprise tax bill.
What Exactly is Severance Pay?
Severance pay is compensation your employer gives you when you're let go. It's not required by federal law in the US, but many companies offer it. Usually, it's based on how long you worked there – like one or two weeks pay for each year of service. Sometimes there's extra for unused vacation days too.
Here's what people often mix up:
| Type | Is it Severance? | Tax Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Final regular paycheck | No | Normal wages |
| Unused vacation/PTO payout | Sometimes included | Always taxed as wages |
| Genuine severance payment | Yes | Supplemental wages |
| Retirement plan distribution | No | Different rules apply |
I remember my buddy Dave got caught by surprise because his "severance" included his unused vacation payout – which got taxed at a higher rate than he expected. Always check the breakdown.
The Nuts and Bolts of Severance Pay Taxation
So how is severance pay taxed? Straight from the IRS playbook: severance is considered "supplemental wages". That means it doesn't get the same treatment as your regular paycheck. Here's where it gets tricky:
Federal Income Tax Withholding
The IRS lets employers choose between two methods for withholding:
| Method | How it Works | Best For | Watch Out For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage Method | Flat 22% federal tax | Single payments under $1 million | Might not cover your actual tax bracket |
| Aggregate Method | Added to regular paycheck and taxed as if you earned that much every pay period | When combined with final paycheck | Can cause massive over-withholding |
That 22% flat rate sounds okay until you realize if you normally pay 24% or 32% in taxes? You owe more come April. Happened to my neighbor Carla last year. She got a $20K severance with 22% withheld ($4,400), but since she's in the 32% bracket, she owed another $2,000 at tax time. Brutal.
2023 Federal Tax Brackets (Single Filer)
- 10%: Up to $11,000
- 12%: $11,001 - $44,725
- 22%: $44,726 - $95,375
- 24%: $95,376 - $182,100
- 32%: $182,101 - $231,250
- 35%: $231,251 - $578,125
- 37%: Over $578,125
See the problem? If your severance pushes you into the 24% or 32% bracket, that 22% withholding won't cover it.
Social Security and Medicare Taxes (FICA)
This one's non-negotiable. Severance pay gets hit with:
- 6.2% Social Security tax (up to $160,200 in 2023)
- 1.45% Medicare tax (no income limit)
Plus if your total income exceeds $200,000 (single filers), add another 0.9% Medicare surtax. Yeah, they get you coming and going.
State Taxes on Severance Pay
This varies wildly. Where you live seriously impacts how severance pay is taxed:
| State Type | Examples | Severance Tax Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| No Income Tax | Texas, Florida, Nevada | No state tax on severance |
| Flat Tax States | Colorado, Pennsylvania | Fixed percentage (e.g. CO: 4.55%) |
| Progressive Tax States | California, New York, Minnesota | Taxed as regular income |
| Special Cases | Pennsylvania | No tax on severance payments |
Fun fact: When I lived in California, my severance got taxed at 9.3%. Ouch. But my cousin in Florida? Zero state tax on his. Location matters.
Tricky Situations That Mess With Taxation
Lump Sum vs Installments
This decision impacts your taxes more than you might think:
- Lump sum = All taxed in one year. Could push you into higher tax bracket.
- Installments = Spread over multiple years. Might keep you in lower brackets.
Example: $60,000 severance
Lump sum: Entire amount taxed in Year 1
Installments (2 years): $30,000 taxed in Year 1, $30,000 in Year 2
The installments might save you thousands if the lump sum would kick you from the 24% to 32% bracket. But here's the catch – some companies refuse installments. Always negotiate this.
Receiving Severance After Starting a New Job
Getting severance while working a new job? That's when things get messy. Now your total income combines both. Suddenly that severance check could be taxed at 32% instead of 24%. Happened to my former colleague Raj – he started a new job in November, got December severance from his old job, and got hammered at tax time.
Watch Your Signatures: I almost made this mistake. Some severance agreements contain clauses where you waive your right to sue. Once signed? No takebacks. Get an employment lawyer to review anything before signing. $500 consultation could save you thousands.
Tax Reduction Strategies That Actually Work
You've got options to legally minimize what you owe:
Timing Your Severance Receipt
- If possible, defer payment to January (pushes income to next tax year)
- Take installments across calendar years
- Avoid receiving during high-income months
Boost Retirement Contributions
Max out your 401(k) or IRA in the year you receive severance. For 2023, that's $22,500 for 401(k)s ($30,000 if over 50). This directly reduces taxable income. Did this myself in 2020 – dropped $20K into my 401(k) before leaving the company.
Health Insurance Tactics
Use COBRA? Those premiums aren't deductible. But if you qualify for an HSA, contributions reduce taxable income. Or consider Marketplace plans – premiums might be tax-deductible depending on income.
Deduct Job Search Expenses
Track everything:
- Resume preparation fees
- Career coaching services
- Travel expenses for interviews
- Postage and shipping costs
These are miscellaneous deductions subject to 2% of AGI floor. Worth it if you've spent thousands.
Common Severance Tax Mistakes I've Seen
After helping dozens of laid-off colleagues, here's what screws people:
- Forgetting about tax brackets: That extra $5K could cost you thousands more in taxes.
- Ignoring state taxes: Especially if moving states post-layoff.
- Mishandling retirement rollovers: Direct rollovers avoid penalties. Indirect? You've got 60 days or it's taxable.
- Blowing the whole severance: After taxes, that $30K might be $18K. Budget accordingly.
My worst mistake? Not adjusting my W-4 at my new job fast enough. Got double-whammied because severance put me in a higher bracket and my new job wasn't withholding enough. Paid $3,200 in penalties.
Severance Pay Tax FAQs
Is severance pay taxed differently than regular income?
Yes and no. For federal tax purposes, it's taxed as ordinary income. But withholding rules differ – employers often use a flat 22% rate instead of your regular rate. State tax treatment varies too, which brings us to...
How is severance pay taxed in California vs Texas?
Massive difference. California taxes severance as regular income (up to 12.3%). Texas has no state income tax, so zero state tax on severance. My friend in San Jose paid 38% total tax on his severance. His identical twin in Austin paid 28%. Location matters.
Can unemployment benefits affect severance taxation?
Indirectly. Some states reduce unemployment if you get severance. But unemployment itself is taxable income! So if you collect both, you could have higher total taxable income.
What if I get severance after leaving the country?
Still taxable as US income if you're a citizen or resident alien. You might qualify for Foreign Earned Income Exclusion ($120,000 for 2023), but severance counts as US-source income. Complex situation – talk to a cross-border tax specialist.
Are there exemptions for older workers?
No special exemptions. But if you're over 55 and take your severance as a lump sum, consider funneling $7,000 extra into your IRA ($1,000 catch-up bonus). Every bit helps.
Practical Next Steps After Reading This
Here's what to do immediately:
- Request payment details in writing
Ask HR: "Is this lump sum or installments? What state taxes will be withheld?" - Calculate rough tax liability
Add severance to your year's income. Use IRS Tax Tables or online calculator. - Consult a CPA for 1 hour
Worth every penny. Bring: severance agreement, last pay stub, estimated new job income. - Adjust withholding at new job
Fill out new W-4 accounting for severance income. - Set aside 25-40% for taxes
Put it in a high-yield savings account. Don't touch it.
Look, navigating how severance pay is taxed feels overwhelming when you're already stressed about job loss. I get it. But taking these steps saved me nearly $7,000 in taxes during my last layoff. Worth the effort.
Final thought: Getting laid off stings. Finding an unexpected tax bill months later? That's salt in the wound. But here's the upside – once you understand how severance pay taxation works, you're in control. You've got this.
Leave a Message