So you're heading to Payson, huh? Smart move. I remember my first trip there – thought I'd just see some pine trees and call it a day. Boy, was I wrong. This place sneaks up on you. One minute you're driving through the desert, next thing you know you're in this mountain town full of surprises. Let's cut through the generic lists you've seen elsewhere. Here's the real scoop on things to do in Payson from someone who's been there more times than I can count.
Outdoor Stuff That Actually Excites You
Most guides throw the same three hikes at you. Not this one. Payson's outdoors scene has layers.
Tonto Natural Bridge: Worth the Hype?
Yeah, it's on every list. But here's what they don't tell you: the parking situation sucks. Get there before 9 AM or you'll circle like a vulture. Once you're in though... wow. That 183-foot travertine bridge? Photos don't do it justice. Bring grippy shoes – the rocks near the waterfall get slippery as heck.
| Trail Name | Difficulty | Length | Best Time | Special Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gowan Trail | Moderate | 0.5 miles | Spring mornings | Best bridge views |
| Anna Mae Trail | Strenuous | 0.75 miles | Fall afternoons | Steep but less crowded |
| Waterfall Trail | Easy | 300 yards | Summer weekdays | Wheelchair accessible |
Cost: $7 per adult. Open 9 AM - 5 PM daily except Christmas. Pro tip: Pack a lunch. The picnic area under the pines beats their overpriced snack bar.
Secret Swimming Holes (Shhh!)
Water Wheel Falls isn't so secret anymore, but upstream? That's where magic happens. Park at the lot off Houston Mesa Road ($10 parking pass required), walk past the main falls, and scramble up the creek about 15 minutes. You'll find pools so clear you'll think they're Photoshopped. Just watch for flash floods after rain – this ain't a joke.
My personal favorite? Horton Creek. Nobody goes there because it's not flashy. Just peaceful cold water and dragonflies. Find the trailhead off Highway 260 east of town.
Fishing That Doesn't Suck
Look, I've wasted hours at bone-dry fishing spots recommended by blogs. Not here. These actually produce:
| Spot | Fish Types | Best Bait | License Required? | My Personal Take |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Green Valley Park | Trout, catfish | PowerBait | Yes | Kid-friendly but busy |
| Bear Canyon Lake | Rainbow trout | Spinners | Yes | Hike required - worth it |
| East Verde River | Smallmouth bass | Crickets | Yes | Shady spots perfect for summer |
Licenses cost $37 for non-residents (available at Walmart on Beeline Highway). Want free fishing? Try the third Saturday in June – Arizona's Free Fishing Day.
Stuff to Do in Payson When You Hate Hiking
Not everyone wants to sweat. Here's what actually entertains regular humans:
Museum Hopping (Yes, Seriously)
The Rim Country Museum surprises people. It's not some dusty shack – they've got a legit 1880s ranch house and native artifacts that'll make you stare. Open Tuesday-Saturday 10-4. $5 admission. Their "Zane Grey Room" makes you appreciate how tough early settlers were. Air-conditioned, too – crucial in summer.
Eating Your Way Through Town
Skip the chains. These places have character:
| Restaurant | Specialty | Price Range | Hours | Why I Go Back |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Old County Inn | Pulled Pork Nachos | $$ | 11am-9pm daily | Smoky flavors you can't fake |
| Crosswinds Restaurant | Chicken Fried Steak | $$ | 6am-8pm daily | Breakfast all day - crispy hash browns |
| Brick House 747 | Green Chile Burger | $$ | 11am-9pm (closed Tue) | Avocado added free if you ask nice |
Surprise standout? Gerardo's Italian. Yeah, Italian in the mountains. Their vodka sauce would make my Nonna nod in approval. Hidden behind a gas station – don't judge.
Weirdly Cool Shops
Main Street looks sleepy until you start poking around. Old Time Candy Company sells Black Jack gum and candy cigarettes – instant nostalgia trip. Pine Creek Fudge makes maple-walnut fudge that's worth the cavities. Opens at 10 AM. Get there early; they run out of caramel by noon.
Downstairs from the fudge shop? A knife store run by a guy named Hank who'll teach you sharpening tricks if you're not busy. Only in Payson.
Local Secret: Second Saturday Art Walk (May-Oct). Galleries stay open late serving wine and cheese. Feels fancy but zero pretension.
Seasonal Things to Do in Payson
This town transforms completely:
Winter - Snow Without the Crowds
Flagstaff gets mobbed. Payson? Not so much. When snow hits:
- Cross-country skiing on Rim Road near Woods Canyon Lake (rentals at REI in Phoenix or buy used at Payson Sporting Goods)
- Free sled hills at Rumsey Park (corner of McLane and Rancho) - bring your own tube
- Cozy cabins with fireplaces - Canyon Point Cabins has wood-burning stoves and pet-friendly units
Road warning: Highway 87 gets icy. Carry chains November-March. Seriously.
Summer - Beat the Phoenix Heat
When it's 115° down there, Payson stays around 85°. Prime waterfall season too. My routine:
- Morning hike at Horton Creek (shade till 11 AM)
- Lunch at Fargo's Steakhouse (their patio misters work miracles)
- Afternoon nap in a hammock at Green Valley Park
- Dinner at Macky's Grill watching elk graze behind the restaurant
Check fire restrictions before campfires. They'll ticket you during dry spells.
Family Things to Do in Payson That Don't Cause Meltdowns
Traveling with kids? I feel you. These work:
Shoofly Indian Ruins - History Comes Alive
Unlike roped-off ruins, here you walk among 700-year-old walls. Free admission (donation box). Open sunrise to sunset. Grab the pamphlet at the entrance - without it, you're just looking at rocks. Kids love spotting pottery shards (look but don't touch!).
Green Valley Park - The Ultimate Playground
Three lakes connected by paths. Feed ducks (bring peas, not bread). Rent paddleboats ($15/hour). Playgrounds designed for different age groups. Clean restrooms matter when you're potty-training. Open 6 AM - 10 PM.
Payson Movie Theaters - Cheap Rainy Day Escape
Sawmill Theatres matinees cost $6.50. Small screens but buttery popcorn. Check showtimes at paysonmovie.com. Pro tip: Their leather recliners in Theater 3 are the secret upgrade.
Things to Do in Payson for Free (Really)
Vacations add up. These won't cost a dime:
- Star gazing at Rim View Overlook - Milky Way visible most nights. Pack blankets.
- Historic walking tour - Grab map at visitor center. See the jail from 1936.
- Thursday night concerts - Summer months at Green Valley Park amphitheater.
- Payson Farmers Market - Saturdays 8 AM-noon (May-Oct). Free samples galore.
Underrated Freebie: The Swiss Village lighting display at Christmas. Thousands of lights synchronized to music. Feels like Hallmark movie magic.
Payson Trip Essentials: Stuff You Need to Know
Hard-won advice from my mistakes:
Getting There Without Losing Your Mind
From Phoenix: Take AZ-87 (Beeline Highway). Not I-17 - that goes to Flagstaff. 90-minute drive normally. Friday afternoons? Double it. Construction near Sunflower is brutal. Check Az511.com for closures.
No Uber. Like, at all. Dirt Road Shuttle does airport runs but book 48 hours ahead.
Where to Stay: Beyond Motels
| Accommodation | Best For | Price Range/Night | Booking Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Majestic Mountain Inn | Families | $120-$180 | Ask for remodeled rooms |
| Kohl's Ranch Lodge | Romance | $190-$300 | Creekside rooms worth upgrade |
| Payson Campgrounds | Budget travelers | $28-$40 | Reserve 6 months ahead online |
My go-to? Christopher Creek Lodge cabins. No TV, just creek sounds. Bring groceries though - kitchenettes available.
Timing Your Visit Right
- Crowds: Avoid Memorial Day weekend and August monsoon season
- Wildflowers: Late April - early May
- Fall Colors: Late October (check Payson Weather on Facebook)
- Hotel Deals: January-February weekdays
Your Payson Questions Answered (No Fluff)
Q: Is Payson worth visiting in winter?
A: Absolutely if you like snow without crowds. Trails get icy though – microspikes recommended.
Q: What unique things to do in Payson most tourists miss?
A: The haunted tour at the Oxbow Saloon (ask for Gary), and gem hunting at Deer Creek Mine (pay dirt buckets $20).
Q: Where can I swim safely in Payson?
A: Water Wheel Falls main pool is supervised in summer. For kids, the Green Valley Park splash pad opens Memorial Day.
Q: How many hiking trails are accessible year-round?
A: About 60% stay snow-free below 5,000 ft. Check with Payson Ranger District for current conditions.
Q: What's the one thing I shouldn't miss?
A: Sunrise at the Mogollon Rim. Drive to Rim View Overlook, bring coffee. Life looks different from 7,000 feet.
Final thought? Payson feels like Arizona's best-kept secret. Phoenix folks escape here but tourists blow right past. Their loss. The pines smell different up here. The stars burn brighter. Give it three days minimum – one for waterfalls, one for history, one for doing absolutely nothing under a ponderosa. Trust me, you'll start planning your return before you've even left.
Leave a Message